cashew: close up picture of Minako's transformation pen (SailorMoon // pen is mightier)
[personal profile] cashew
Just a quick thought on Caladbolg weapons quest and how if they wanted to reward you with a free/cheap ascended weapon for any potential class, they should've picked very different weapons. My recommendation for the 5 weapons are:

Sword - meta for warriors, mesmers, guardians, revenants, rangers in at least one game mode or more

Dagger - meta for elementalists, necromancers, thieves in at least one game mode or more

Pistol - meta for engineers and thieves in at least one game mode or more

Staff - meta for thieves, elementalists, mesmers, revenants, rangers in at least one game mode or more

Hammer - meta for guardians, engineers, revenants in at least one game mode or more

With this suggestion, only necromancers get shorted in the sense of having only one weapon choice that's meta - until you realize that necromancers literally only have dagger as a meta weapon. Everything else they use is considered not-meta, so... If we're looking at sheer coverage in terms of things the class can use (irrespective of meta), it's as follows:

Sword - warriors, guardians, revenants, mesmers, rangers, thieves

Dagger - rangers, thieves, elementalists, necromancers

Pistol - engineers, thieves, mesmers

Staff - guardians, revenants, rangers, thieves, elementalists, necromancers, mesmers

Hammer - warriors, guardians, revenants, engineers

So the coverage breakdown comes to:
Thieves - 4/5
Guardian - 3/5
Revenant - 3/5
Rangers - 3/5
Mesmers - 3/5
Warrior - 2/5
Engineer - 2/5
Elementalists - 2/5
Necromancer - 2/5

Versus the current breakdown of compatibility, which is: (shield, scepter, dagger, gs, sword)
Guardian - 4/5
Mesmer - 4/5
Warrior - 3/5
Ranger - 3/5
Necromancer - 3/5
Revenant - 2/5
Thief - 2/5
Elementalist - 2/5
Engineer - 1/5 ←And not even meta!

Basically, under my proposal, Necromancer and Guardians get 33% less choice, and Warriors and Mesmers get 25% less choice; but Revenants gets 33% more choice, Thieves 50% more choice, and Engineers actually have a choice. I think that's a pretty fair pay off.

Edit: Here's the mock ups of how those weapons that were not could have looked like.

Date: 2017-03-18 07:50 pm (UTC)
tanithryudo: (Default)
From: [personal profile] tanithryudo
I think they just had to have greatsword as a story thing though.

Date: 2017-03-19 12:01 am (UTC)
tanithryudo: (Default)
From: [personal profile] tanithryudo
Collecting all 5 skins is really easy though... not really worth an additional ascended weapon.

June 2017

S M T W T F S
    1 2 3
45 67 89 10
1112 1314 151617
1819 2021 222324
252627282930 

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Additional Credits

Tiny Icons provided by Yusuke Kamiyamane. Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License. Custom CSS theme walthers (beatrice) by [personal profile] manual.
Mood icons originally created by Onion Club owner Ethan Lui.
Page generated Jun. 24th, 2017 01:44 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios