cashew: Picture of Zack looking up at the sky (FFVII // zack)
[personal profile] cashew
The problem with GW2 PvE scene - I'm referring to the cooperative play aspect - is that it doesn't give a place for the many tools like boon strip, boon corrupt, and retaliation punishment. Most PvE Bosses are usually just a few big attacks, HP sponge, and...possibly a DPS check by having a timer. This is boring boss design. Here are ways that bosses could be much more interesting.

1. Damage retaliation: Give bosses a strippable/corruptable buff that retaliates damage. And unless removed, will render DPS dead in any attempts at hitting it. Lich boss in the Halloween Labyrinth was a great design that really pushed for the need of a boon strip/corruption class, giving Necros a place in PvE cooperative play.

2. Damage absorption when exceeding damage limit: if the received DPS is over a certain number, say, 20k, then have any excess damage heal the boss rather than continue damage it further. The only way to get around this is if the boss is stunned/dazed/knocked down/float (in other words, hard cc'd), thereby requiring the team to build for more than just DPS.

3. High attack speed, low attack damage: Build a boss that hits with unblockable, undodgeable AoEs that hit at like 600 damage per hit, but hits everyone 30 times per second. This forces the need for damage reduction, plus makes retaliation a useful trait to have for a boss. Confusion will actually do reasonable damage due to the high attack speed of the boss thus making the boss kill himself and the party needs to build highly defensively to simply survive.

4. Enforced battles of attrition: Give bosses regeneration that scales inversely with how many stacks of poison it has. If unpoisoned, bosses will simply heal back up. Other sources of damage merely heals the boss. The only way to defeat the boss is stay alive and attrition it to death. Give bosses healing skills, that if not interrupted/cc'd in time, would heal the boss back up to full, rendering previous work useless. Such a boss renders DPS useless and forces the players to build with sustain in mind instead.

5. Multiple bosses instead of one: Instead of making a single big boss to fight, make the "boss fight" the result of having to fight wave after wave of minions charging at you. Meanwhile, apply a health degeneration buff in the room that can be mitigated by toughness. Again, this forces the final fight into a battle of attrition, rather than focused on a spike of damage to deplete the boss' health. It also places emphasis on sustained damage rather than spike damage, as large damage spikes aren't going to make things go any faster.

6. Scale the boss to player stats, not level/numbers: Give the boss the corresponding stats which counters the team stat make up. High DPS? Exponentially grow the boss HP according to the power/condition damage stats and reduce the time allotted for the encounter. High defense? Exponentially grow the boss armor rating and attack damage. Make it such that building for an extreme will result in less efficiency as opposed to building for a middle of the road make up. There, now all your stats are useful, because the player now tunes the boss according to their armor choice.

There are plenty of more ideas that can be used to make a boss encounter difficult without resorting to scaling up more HP and require more damage. In fact, an encounter where high player damage works against the player is actually the fastest way to break the DPS-tunnel vision meta.

Date: 2017-03-22 12:36 am (UTC)
tanithryudo: (Default)
From: [personal profile] tanithryudo
Are these ideas for open world random bosses, map meta bosses, dungeon/fractal bosses, or raid bosses?

1. I've seen this on the karka bosses, or at least the one in Ember Bay. I also wish they'd used retaliation instead of this on the chak. F*ck chak.

2. I think this may work with organized content. Raids, dungeons, fractals, and map bosses. I don't think it's a good idea to throw them on any random open world boss. Also, you'd need to be aware of the possibility of people using mechanics like this to grief other players.

3. We already got this in game I believe. There's the mordrem thrasher and its trail of goo, the leeching thrasher's ranged attack, or the chak zapper chain lightning knockoff... BTW, confusion damage scales with condition duration and damage, so you can't build just for defense if you want to kill something with confusion.

4. This unfairly biases the fight to/against classes that have access to easy poison though. Also, I don't think there's any skill that only applies poison and not damage, so the "other sources of damage merely heals the boss" clause will just make the fight objectively unbeatable.

5. Isn't that exactly what the Vinewrath fight is? The TD Gerent fight is sorta this also.

6. Possible in instanced fights, but it would be a huge mess to implement in open world. You'd have to constantly adjust for people entering/leaving/afking the fight, as well as people wearing anywhere from masterwork to ascended gear. On the other hand, being forced to purchase gear to pass a single boss will cause some players to ragequit.
Edited Date: 2017-03-22 12:43 am (UTC)

Date: 2017-03-23 06:14 am (UTC)
tanithryudo: (Default)
From: [personal profile] tanithryudo
3. Eh, that sounds a little niche, honestly. If it doesn't force you to spec into condi damage, then all it takes is for the mechanism to become known, and then people would just get the team mez to F2 the boss and everyone else can just call it a day.

4. I guess... though using environmental weapons to pass a boss must already be in the game somewhere...

5. Hrm... aren't a lot of the personal/living story missions kinda this? Like, the one defending Arlene when she hatches, for example.

6. Hah. Yeah, I guess raiders can afford it.

Date: 2017-03-24 01:00 am (UTC)
tanithryudo: (Default)
From: [personal profile] tanithryudo
3. That doesn't make sense... either non-condi-build confusion is strong enough to take down the boss on its own. Or it's not, and a full-condi-build confusion is able to take it down. Or that's still not enough, and you need to have the whole team to spec into condi-build with confusion.

The first isn't a challenge. The second isn't too hard for a group to bring at least one condi-build. The third would make people ragequit.

There's no way that a team of non-condi-build PCs applying confusion will do more confusion damage than a single full-condi-build PC apply confusion, regardless of what the boss does.

4. I don't think survival challenge would make it fun. Just look at the tank meta in WvW and why they nerfed it. Most likely people would just bring standard complement and have using a boon-spammer or healer to provide group defense. Or use the WvW tactic of stack & blast water.

5. I'm pretty sure there are some raids which are similar to this mechanic too...

April 2017

S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
9 1011121314 15
1617 1819202122
232425 26 272829
30      

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Additional Credits

Tiny Icons provided by Yusuke Kamiyamane. Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License. Custom CSS theme walthers (beatrice) by [personal profile] manual.
Mood icons originally created by Onion Club owner Ethan Lui.
Page generated Apr. 28th, 2017 04:13 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios