Thursday, September 16th, 2021

cashew: Kamui holding a bunch of books (X // even heroes read)

An Asian American who wasn't impressed by Shang-Chi.

(〒▽〒)

For nearly two weeks, I was sitting around wondering if I and one other reddit user were the only ones who saw Shang-Chi for what it was: a repackaging of Asian (specifically Chinese) stereotypes that is more palatable to White people without being blatantly racist. I believe the best description was Shang-Chi strikes [him] as an 'improved congee', aka an Asian thing that's been Westernized to appeal to xenophobic Americans.

And lo!

If “Shang-Chi” breaks any ground, though, it won’t be for the quality and nuance of how it represents Asians or Asian Americans, but for the simple fact of that representation. The movie is an Orientalist fantasia that presents the same old tropes in slightly updated, somewhat self-aware, very expensive packaging. Washington Post

I was told by a friend to be patient, as the negative reviews will come as more people watch the movie and make their voices heard, but I still couldn't help but feel like I was in some topsy-turvey world where the stereotypes were being heralded as revolutionary, progressive, and limit-breaking. Glad to see that I've got at least one more person in my corner.

Not gonna lie, it feels good to see my perspective validated in a major newspaper.

Also, very glad to see Morris correctly identified as 帝江 (dijiang) instead of 混沌 (hundun), because Americans are fucking confused. 混沌 has a face, it has ears that can't hear and eyes that don't see. Also, it has four legs instead of six. Gah. It was bothering me so much that people kept calling Morris a 混沌, because it's the wrong creature FFS!

/rant

Also, word to the following:

It’s not enough for me. I’m sorry. I’m not grateful for Shang Chi, because I’m not grateful for scraps from the table anymore.

I want a seat at the table.

I want the table.

I wish more Asian Americans aren't so quick to swallow Hollywood BS and are willing to demand more. They ought to demand more. America doesn't deserve a pat on the back for giving away table scraps. You don't get to feel progressive just because you cast actors of Chinese descent as Chinese characters in a movie. That's not enough.

cashew: dude with sunglasses looking confused (Misc // Haa?)

As much as I hate sports fandom, I find myself still going back to the fútbol circle because...even misanthropes still need human interaction to hate on I guess. Anyway, while my default state towards the English language community is nothing but scorn, the Chinese language community is fractionally better.

Because sometimes, out of the blue, you'll see an influencer post:

​杨过超没超过郭靖?

*roflmao*

(^∀^●)

Chinese fans are gonna Chinese.

And the best part of all of this is when the fans started a war in the comments section over sweet vs savory versions of classical Chinese foods like 粽子、豆腐脑、豆浆. May the battles never end. (Also, the correct answer is sweet 粽子 and 豆浆, savory 豆腐脑, and you are wrong.)

June 2025

S M T W T F S
12345 67
89 1011121314
15161718192021
222324 25262728
2930     

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Page generated Sunday, July 6th, 2025 22:01
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios